Error: Unable to create directory /home/demockra/public_html/wp-content/uploads/2010/09. Is its parent directory writable by the server? Lone Star Rumblings: So Goes the Party
by Scott Unzicker, Contributing Writer
December 14, 2008
Top to bottom, the GOP in Texas seems to be foundering in a sea of disillusionment and infighting. Not just nationally, but in the Lone Star State as well, the Republican flock that gave rise to the Bush dynasty seems to have lost its faith.
The State of the Electorate
If a recent poll from Hill Research Consultants, entitled “Beyond Bush: Texas Republicans in an Obama Era,” is to be believed, Texas voters suffer from “Bush fatigue,” believe that the GOP is “arrogant, racist, corrupt, and unwelcoming” when compared to its Democrat counterparts. A generic R vs. D gubernatorial ballot gives Democrats a clear advantage at both the state representative and gubernatorial levels.
| Generic Ballot Preferences
|
Republicans
|
Democrats
|
| Governor | 31% | 44% |
| State Representative | 31% | 45% |
Other points of interest note that “multiple deceased Democrats handily beat still living Republican office-holders in favorability,” and “Republicans are also failing to connect with younger voters and the Hispanic community.” Considering the state of Texas is growing younger and more Hispanic by the day, the Texas GOP seems to be on the wrong side of demographic trends.
So goes the opinion of the electorate in Texas, once the bread and butter of the Republican Party. They seem disillusioned and wavering in their support of the GOP and its direction. Hill, et al., warn that what happened in Colorado, a decidedly red state in 2000 whose governor, both chambers of the legislature, and both U.S. senators are now all Democratic, could happen in Texas. “The time to ring the alarm bell, if necessary, is now,” declares Hill.
Finally, it must be noted that the poll referenced in detail above was taken November 15-17th, right on the heels of the general election. It’s not unreasonable to speculate that the voters surveyed were encircled by the “Obama halo,” a feel-good sentiment that seemed to wash over much of the country, proud of itself for electing its first African-American president. In general, polls taken in the weeks immediately after an election are not as reliable. Many moderate voters often have a confirmation bias toward the winning candidate or party. However, with that said, the Texas GOP should ignore the results of this poll at their own peril.
Gubernatorial and Senatorial Implications
With the laity in such disarray, it’s no surprise that the Republican Party leadership is struggling to maintain order within its own ranks. Two key Texas Republicans are looking vulnerable, and not necessarily just from Democratic vectors.

President Bush (L), Lt. Gen. Blum (C), and Governor Perry (R), showing off his fashionable cell phone belt clip
Sitting Governor Rick Perry, who won reelection in 2006 with only 39.3% of the vote, announced in April his intention to run again in 2010. Texas does not place limits on reelecting its governor, but a third term would be unprecedented and apparently not necessarily welcomed by some of the Republican elite.
On December 4th,Kay Bailey Hutchison, the senior U.S. Senator from Texas, filed paperwork with the Texas Ethics Commission to form an exploratory committee for the office of governor. The filing was not revelatory, as she’s been dodgy for months about directly answering the “would she or wouldn’t she run” question, and noises were even made about her running against Perry in 2006 and 2002. What was surprising was the speed with which the two camps traded barbs after her filing.
Hutchison initially remarked that there’s “too much bitterness, too much anger, too little trust, too little consensus and too much infighting” in Austin. Mark Miner, a Perry spokesman, replied “Kay Bailout has been talking about running for governor and passing legislation for years, and neither has ever happened.”
It will be an interesting gubernatorial primary in 2010, indeed.
Other Political Rumblings
Hutchison’s U.S. Senate seat does not come up for re-election until 2012. Should she vacate the Senate before then (she doesn’t have to in order to run for state office), the governor has the power to appoint a replacement. The word around the campfire is that sitting Lt. Governor,David Dewhurst, would be at the top of Perry’s short list.
Third behind the governor and lieutenant governor in power, the Speaker of the Texas House is elected at the beginning of each new congressional session, the next one beginning January 13, 2009. Rep. Tom Craddick, R-Midland, whose leadership style has been likened to that of Vlad the Impaler, has held the Speakership since 2003.
He has caused controversy and consternation among both Democrats and Republicans by his heavy-handed use, some would say abuse, of the powers given him as speaker by the Texas Constitution. Not only has he refused to recognize representatives motioning for house rules changes that may challenge his power, he has even refused to allow direct votes to remove him from power brought before the House by half a dozen of his fellow Republicans at the end of the last session. He thought it would set a bad precedent. Those who have challenged him from his own party have found themselves being passed over for desirable positions that their seniority may have given them dibs on.
No less than eleven representatives, seven of which are from his own party, will challenge Craddick for the Speakership for the next legislative session. On Friday, December 12th, Rep. Dan Gattis, R-Georgetown, filed a constitutional proposition that would allow the removal of a speaker in mid-session with the approval of 100 of the 150 representatives. Obviously, Craddick is not a popular guy, even among his own people.
Overall Lone Star Outlook
With a core constituency that no longer seems to trust its leadership or the direction the party is taking, the GOP in Texas is a rudderless mess. Its captains can’t decide who should be at the helm, and Texas Democrats are eagerly waiting in the wings to stage a mutiny the scale of which would be rivaled only by the 1994 “Republican Revolution.” In 2010, it looks like they’ll have their chance.










Just in case anyone is interested in the latest info relating to this story, I’ll post some numbers that just came in, and put up a select quote. I’ll keep this very short: General election voters have a 67% favorable rating of Hutchison to Perry’s 51%. Republican primary voters like Hutchison at 55% favorable to Perry’s 31%. This information comes from a poll by Voter Consumer Research, Inc. paid for by Hutchison’s “exploratory committee.” If you want a .pdf of it, let me know. Finally, former Texas GOP chair, Tom Pauken, said to the Dallas Morning News “They’ve made a mess of things in Washington in the last eight years. Now they’re going to come home to Texas and tell us how to fix the Republican Party in our state?”
Update: Tom Craddick has officially bowed out of the race for Texas Speaker of the House. In short: a group of house Republicans dubbed the ABC (Anyone But Craddick) group got together and, with the backing of a large number of house Democrats, mustered enough pledged votes to front Rep. Joe Straus R-San Antonio as their candidate for speaker. They published that list of pledged votes on the evening of Sunday, January 4th. Craddick’s reelection as speaker was contingent upon the backing of several of the Democrats on that list. When he figured out he just didn’t have the votes to win, he backed out. This created a vacuum for a candidate for the speakership that would please the former Craddick-philes. In a hurried dinner meeting late Sunday, they came up with Amarillo Rep. John Smithee as their man.
Here’s where it gets interesting: Will some or all of the Republicans and/or Democrats that jumped Craddick’s ship now come back over to the Smithee camp now that Craddick is out of the way? Nobody knows.
The plot thickens.